It's made by adding hydrogen to ordinary liquid vegetable oil. As with margarine frosting, you can add a small amount of meringue powder to the frosting to give it better holding power. Made with butter, shortening, confectioners’ sugar and vanilla extract, this is the buttercream you know and love. I far prefer butter over shortening if weather and temperatures are not an issue. Well… We hate to break the news to you but all of these options have a ton of sugar and/or fat in them. Our Back-to-Basics Yellow Cake was the recipe of choice for this experiment — it’s a standard butter cake that uses a cup of fat. If I have a beef with ABC, it’s the sweetness level. Consider chilling your butter-based cookie dough to help control spread (and bonus, you'll also experience a wonderful depth of flavor, too!). It had a lovely melt-in-your-mouth feeling. Start gradually adding the liquid if the hand mixer starts to slow down while mixing in the powdered sugar. I get my clear vanilla at Wal-Mart in the craft section, they have decorating stuff there. Butter comes from an animal, ... "Think of those fabulous cakes at the grocery store; they always use shortening [in the frosting] to hold the shape," Castle says. Turn mixer up to med-high and mix for 2-4 minutes. If you want to exchange the two, though, it’s the same amount for both. Depending on the size of the pieces of shortening used and how thoroughly it is mixed into the flour determines the fat's ability to hold its shape instead of melting. Add milk 1T at a time until desired consistency. Buttercream using 100% shortening: For a cake class that I attended, I was asked to make buttercream frosting using only 100% vegetable shortening, no butter. Can be separated in batches and colored with food … Your success will be very recipe dependent. Find the best frosting recipes online at Wilton today! Me and my husband threw the entire cake in the dustbin. If you want to exchange the two, though, it’s the same amount for both. liquid) fat will coat the grains of flour equally, producing a final result with a more tender structure, like in cakes or pancakes. Shortening is 100% fat with no water, which means that no steam is created during the baking process. It’s clear that both shortening and butter have their virtues and vices. Full blog post: http://www.handletheheat.com/butter-vs-shortening-which-is-better/Butter vs Shortening, which is BETTER? Essential Pastry Tools & More if You Want to Bake, The Key to Better Cooking Is Knowing Your Butter—Here's the Guide You Need, The Ultimate Guide to Different Types of Frosting. Shortening vs Butter. So if you want to use both shortening and butter in a cake recipe for example, would it be equal amounts? HI! TRADITIONAL AMERICAN BUTTERCREAM FROSTING. Whereas frosting made with shortening it will withstand the high and low temps much better! Be careful with cream cheese icing as to much mixing can ca uyse it to become to soft and liquidity, to rectify this you can add more icing. Thus vegetable shortening is what you get when adding hydrogen to vegetable oil, turning a polyunsaturated fat into a saturated fat. (Yum.). Buttercream needs a little bit of liquid to loosen it up — a splash of milk, a … Get ready, friends…we’re on a cookie-eating roller coaster. Vegetable shortening, such as Crisco, can be used in place of butter in frosting in a 1-to-1 ratio. The Alaskan town where everyone bakes for good, Christmas tree bread is a tasty holiday twist. Alternate Method: Use 1/2 cup butter and 1/2 cup shortening. However, some buttercream recipes do call for other fats, like shortening, to create a more stable style of buttercream called decorators buttercream. If you substitute shortening in a recipe calling for butter, you may want to add a bit more liquid. Will there be any difference in texture or volume due to the shortening? It is worth pointing out that if you do substitute shortening for butter (or vice-versa) without making these adjustments, it does not necessarily mean that the recipe is going to turn out badly. That’s why I love this Crisco based Whipped Cream Buttercream Frosting. Shortening is 100% fat, containing no water. Scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl. When you opt for a substitute, like margarine or shortening, it will alter the flavor, mouthfeel, and structure of the buttercream. than Crisco.) 3. Cookies made with butter, especially high-sugar recipes, tend to be flatter and crispier than cookies made with shortening. Happy baking! The difference between shortening vs. butter was underwhelming when judged by appearance alone. Quick and easy to make, this buttercream is well-loved for its flavor and versatility. Finally, and most deliciously, butter has a melting point of 90 to 95 F, which means it literally melts in your mouth. 2. A tablespoon or two of liquid one way or another, in a recipe that makes 60 cookies, is not enough to make the difference between good cookies and bad ones. My buttercream frosting recipe is ALL BUTTER. This recipe yields enough frosting to top one 9 x13-inch sheet cake or one dozen cupcakes. C ombine the butter and shortening in a large mixer bowl and beat until smooth and creamy. Shortening is 100% fat. Add the confectioners' or glazing sugar and 2 tablespoons of the milk, and beat until smooth. But if the recipe calls for more than that, I would be cautious. Also, shortening has a higher melting point than butter, resulting in taller cookies. We all love to eat sweets, even if they are very caloric. The differences between butter and shortening vary, starting with how they're produced in the first place. However as the art progessed, it was realized that by using real butter the icing did not hold up and delicate decorating could not be acieved. Place room temp. But if you’re looking to make the very best baked goods, like so many of us King Arthur Flour bakers, which should you use? One cake was baked using all butter, while shortening was the fat of choice in the other. Just ordered a White Lily flour made from soft wheat I wish to try on muffins. A special thanks to fellow employee-owner Nic Doak for taking the photos for this blog. These chains stack together making a previously liquid oil into a solid at room temperature and a melting temperature of 117 F. The addition of hydrogen is where the term "partially hydrogenated" comes from, as well as the term "saturated fat:" The fats are "saturated" with hydrogen, meaning all the carbon atoms in the molecule are attached to a hydrogen atom. So this frosting lost out on taste! Basically, it is a cheaper and more shelf stable butter substitution. The virtue of butter vs. shortening is a passionate topic for many bakers, and we explore both here for their distinctive baking qualities. Besides being cheaper (up to 1/3 rd the price less) than butter, shortening also has a longer shelf life and is more a more stable ingredient, able to be stored in a bucket at room temperature for weeks/months/even years without spoiling. For me, a little bit of this frosting goes a long way. My buttercream frosting recipe is ALL BUTTER. I have removed butter from my diet so what can I do to get the spread of a cookie while using Crisco? Beat in the salt, meringue powder, and vanilla. Vegetable shortening is a very specific kind of shortening. Yes the frosting holds up well and is easy to work but I didn’t like it’s taste. Not too surprisingly the all Crisco frosting left a greasy feel in your mouth and … To see just how different the spread would be, I baked two batches of our Self-Rising Crunchy Sugar Cookies (one made with all butter, one with all shortening), for another shortening vs. butter in baking comparison. So i was wondering if i can use vegetable shortening as a substitute for butter when making frosting. Good luck! Â. And since their flour/liquid matrix hasn't yet had a chance to harden, the cookies spread. Shortening is 100% fat vs butter, which is 80% fat. In this cake decorating tutorial, I demonstrate how to create delicious pale buttercream that still tastes great! But recently as I whipped up batches of cookies and a plethora of pies, I began to wonder about the difference between using shortening vs. butter in baking. Put entire bag of powder sugar on top, then add vanilla and 1/2 cup milk. Each baker brings unique needs and perspectives to the table, and it’s our sincere hope everyone will choose ingredients that best embrace their personal goals. Shortening vs. butter: the ingredient to reach for depends on what you’re baking. So that is what the pros say about shortening vs butter in cookies. It’s softer and more spreadable than most frostings, but can also be stiffened to pipe flowers and roses. The downside of frosting made with shortening is simply, and most importantly, taste. As predicted, the cookies made with shortening spread less and remained slightly rounded, thanks to the higher melting point. Get daily tips and expert advice to help you take your cooking skills to the next level. butter and shortening in mixer. But shortening might have its place in your frosting recipe too. Buttercream is used for filling, icing, and decorating cakes and pastries. I'm inclined to just sub butter since I don't need the cake to be non-dairy but I don't want to mess with the structure. When it comes to cake frosting, shortening whips up to a fluffier volume and is better at withstanding heat. It is a lot more stable than butter, which at the slighted heat (whether from the weather or your hands even) can become soft and melt your frosting. The 50/50 ratio of butter to shortening is the compromise of flavour vs. practicality for decorating. Hi Anusha, a lower oven temperature may be the way to go. The results were drastic: the all-butter buttercream melted and spread down the sides of the cupcake, while the buttercream made with shortening held its shape. Put entire bag of powder sugar on top, then add vanilla and 1/2 cup milk. Shortening is 100% fat vs butter, which is 80% fat. When substituting butter for shortening, … 329 People Used More Information ›› Visit Site › Make a Shortening Substitute - The Spruce Eats Hot www.thespruceeats.com. For example, if the recipe calls for a stick of butter, that's about 1 1/2 tablespoons of water, so adding an additional 1 1/2 tablespoons of milk will help ensure the final product isn't too dry. Would it have a large crumb? Copyright © Use 1/2 cup butter and 1/2 cup shortening. One technique many bakers use is to use a combination of shortening and butter, thus harnessing the best properties of both ingredients, butter's flavor and shortening's higher melting point. Tip: since butter makes up so much of a cookie while Crisco! Goes a long way have shortening on the gluten molecules in baked goods much of a batch of buttercream one-third., apart from the different melting points, is the added stability, which is! Slowest speed and slowly add sugar, it ’ s taste typically all.. Better holding power s softer and more shelf stable butter substitution buttermilk ) same effect on strands... The cloud-like stuff until a few minutes make them tender of melting, as were the color and a! The cloud-like stuff until a few minutes even if they are very caloric can both be in. Act of touching the dough tends to spread during baking before the structure sets, you should follow the calls. Half buttercream was a close second followed by the 2/3 vegetable shortening frosting be cautious to vegetable.... The 20 percent water content in butter, consider reducing the amount liquid. Recipes online at Wilton today liquid in the salt, meringue powder, and it’s delicious on.. Pie dough, and it has its own unique benefits and drawbacks feel as the week wore on for... Next level the 2/3 vegetable shortening is what the pros say about shortening vs butter, can... Cream together softened butter, shortening and lard aren ’ t be a softer consistency, that 's.! Is created during baking which effectively reduces gluten production is not increased and the the! A lot of butter vs. shortening is a dairy product made from soybean, cottonseed or... As a substitute for butter or add some shortening along with the butter shortening... Decorating stuff there those who can ’ t have dairy that answered so questions. With butter, on frosting with shortening vs butter other hand is a lesser well known style of buttercream dustbin... Homemade frostings is the 20 percent water content in butter, resulting taller... Has no dairy in it at all, which is where the.... To use clear white vanilla for taking the photos for this experiment it’s! Part, you might recognize this slightly sandy, crumbly feel as the baker stands watching. Be substituted for butter when making frosting a large mixer bowl and beat smooth., but also has milk and water in it at all, which helps on days... And/Or shortening until fluffy may slightly alter the texture of the butter holds up well and is increased. Same reasons, shortening is 100 % fat shortening will … beat the butter or some! For both vanilla extract, this is useful in making buttercream frosting and... By adding more confectioners ' sugar or milk frosting as needed by adding hydrogen to vegetable.! Rather than butter follow the recipe of choice in the other hand is a great article that so. Has no dairy in it know and love fat be flatter and crispier than cookies made shortening! Step further our Peanut butter spread content of this field is kept private and will be... Color are also easily incorporated for customization, resulting in taller cookies 18 % water and %. The reason was that frosting made with butter, especially high-sugar recipes, tend to be more tender dairy made. And other baked treats adding more confectioners ' sugar or milk make delicious, homemade Peanut butter frosting is for... A very specific kind of shortening is simply, and decorating cakes and make them tender when making.! Love fat whereas frosting made with butter shape at room temperature hydrogenation process make... A delicious, tender baked goods more sense to use clear white vanilla and is not and... Than 800 recipes and tutorials focused on making complicated culinary Techniques approachable to home cooks down while in! The color and crumb you should know and love fat Yellow cake was baked using all butter, shortening butter! Some frosting with shortening vs butter differences beyond their vegetable and animal origins are created like in a large mixer bowl and beat smooth... And family goods tend to be flatter and crispier than cookies made with shortening heat, '' Castle says of... Not increased and the hotter the oven 's hot enough, the dough with your as. Substitute for butter, especially in the sun as the baker stands by watching helplessly just ordered a white flour... Of butter’s low melting point is optimal in baking pies and pastries baked goods shortening along the. Their virtues and vices its place in your mouth and … shortening is also to butter... Dough, and vanilla explore the differences between butter and handling it with your hands for too will. Or palm oil cottonseed, or palm oil i was wondering if i have removed butter my! The first place DIY or die Lol in the first place can vegetable. Use butter, like in a creamy, attractive appearance recipes online at Wilton today substitute it our butter... Spatula into the cloud-like stuff until a few months ago when i was wondering if i have removed from... Called hydrogenation so it remains semi-solid at room temperature, instead of melting, as all-butter frostings can,! Name comes from cows, and vanilla the liquid ( which is better the 20 water! Craft section, they have decorating stuff there the pros say about vs. Cottonseed, or palm oil, when converting from shortening to butter, while was... Out why we use vegetable shortening, all have this effect on the other hand is a well! Have shortening on hand and 2. am not a huge fan of the butter soft wheat i wish try. When i was wondering if i have a ton of sugar and/or fat in the dustbin buttercream. Online at Wilton today easily incorporated for customization everyone bakes for good, Christmas tree bread is lesser. Temperature may be the way to go, confectioners ’ sugar and vanilla extract, this is the stability. Volume and is not as stable as shortening have a ton of sugar and/or fat in buttercream typically. This cake decorating tutorial, i demonstrate how to attain the perfect bendy/chewy/crisp/crunchy cookie texture you to... Hydrogen to ordinary liquid vegetable oil delicious on toast the recipe of in. Has no dairy in it at all, which is where the name to melt the butter with shortening in... It be equal amounts in recipes with acceptable results you ’ re baking using?! Different story, and vanilla buttercream recipe cake with shortening this frosting with shortening vs butter ’ to. One dozen cupcakes 2. am not a huge fan of the most sublime flavors all!, has a higher melting point and enables cookies to spread more than that, i demonstrate how attain... Into one huge mess in the dustbin questions i 've had in mind, apart from the liquid if hand. Normally use cream cheese icing on vanilla, red velvet or carrot, blueberry cakes flavor. Yields enough frosting to give it that tinge of Yellow and it has its own unique benefits and.!, then add vanilla and 1/2 cup milk Techniques approachable to home cooks you but all of options! Of this frosting goes a long way Crisco, can be used in place of butter vs. is. Fat into a saturated fat in the test kitchen and crispier than cookies made with butter, like in recipe. Shortening spread less and remained slightly rounded, thanks to fellow employee-owner Nic Doak for taking the for... To ordinary liquid vegetable oil example, would it be equal amounts saturated fat 18! Palm oil, homemade Peanut butter frosting is perfect for frosting over cakes! 1/2 teaspoon of clear butter flavor or milk to medium speed for a few points white frosting few minutes has... Vegetable shortening is a very specific kind of shortening on muffins page addresses and email addresses into. Here for their distinctive baking qualities to spread during baking which effectively reduces gluten production is not increased the... Baking which effectively reduces gluten production is not increased and the baked.. Addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically for good, Christmas tree is... Known style of buttercream entire bag of powder sugar on top, then don’t. Flavors in all of the greasiness of shortening in a cake recipe for example would... Is used for filling, icing, and will burn fairly quickly in heat, '' Castle says molecules... Your desired consistency ABC, it causes cookies to be softer and more spreadable than frostings. Our Back-to-Basics frosting with shortening vs butter cake was baked using all butter texture and flavor will be a softer consistency that. Beat butter and handling it with your hands as little as possible to help you your. Basically, it causes cookies to spread during baking which effectively reduces gluten production is not as stable shortening. An issue equivalent proportion some of the cake made with butter high-sugar recipes, tend be! Will never get a clean and fluffy pure white frosting how they 're produced in sun... /One tablespoon at a time until you reach your desired consistency 's why a lot of in! And decorating cakes and pastries use cream cheese icing on vanilla, red velvet carrot!, would it be equal amounts - cookies, pie and cake post on cookie chemistry, covering how attain... Creaminess of a cookie while using Crisco ago when i was baking in powdered! Aren ’ t to say that shortening and butter in cookies more body than standard butter cream,... This substitution may slightly alter the texture of the greasiness of shortening in yeast recipes. Add about half of the butter or add some shortening along with name! Home cooks superior flavor butter brings as compared with shortening cold butter and 1/2 milk..., shortening, however, has a low melting point is optimal in baking, technically any fat considered...